2. Novelty and Differentiation
0
1-2
3-4
5
2.1 Industry & Competitor
Differentiation
10%
LEVEL 0Fails to identify clear differentiation. Follows existing
practices or general industry standards with no new elements.
LEVEL 1Identifies conceptual differences or partial functional,
but
lacks clarity on superiority or supporting evidence.
LEVEL 2Explains tangible differentiation compared to the
industry or
competitors (e.g., cost, quality, speed, or customer experience) with supporting
rationale, but lacks clear quantitative evidence.
LEVEL 3Demonstrates a clear Unique Value Proposition (UVP)
compared
to the industry or competitors, backed by quantitative evidence or actual
results
that prove a sustainable competitive advantage.
2.2 Advanced Technology Development and
Business Model Innovation
10%
LEVEL 0Uses existing market solutions directly. Adopts
Off-the-shelf
solutions without developing internal knowledge or intellectual property.
LEVEL 1Involves some level of Customization or Configuration,
but
the Core Technology belongs to others and the primary components remain
unchanged.
LEVEL 2Integrates various technologies or methodologies to
develop
specific Core Modules/Algorithms/Platform Components. Creates technical
differentiation but does not yet possess full ownership of the
technology.
LEVEL 3Develops entire core components resulting in Proprietary
Technology, Unique Products/Processes, or Innovative Business Models. Supported
by
empirical evidence such as prototypes, full roll-outs, Patents, Copyrights,
Trade
Secrets, or models that are highly difficult to replicate.
2.3 First in market/ First in industry
5%
LEVEL 0Not first implement (Sell or use) in CP
LEVEL 1First implement (Sell or use) in CP
LEVEL 2First in some segment (Market or industry)
Process: At least 1 criterion must be met
- No prior implementation of this process within the same market segment.
- Industry-recognized technical acceptance or validation within the same
industry.
Product: At least 1 criterion must be met
- Absence of direct competition offering a similar product within the same
segment.
- Launched at least 6 months ahead of competitors.
- Distinct Differentiation
LEVEL 3First in martket (Country/ Industry/ Regional) or First
in
industry
Process: At least 1 criterion must be met
- Supported by official industry reports or verified by subject matter
experts.
- Received recognized industry awards, professional certifications, or formal
expert
validation.
Product: At least 1 criterion must be met
- Successfully launched ahead of all competitors in the market.
- No existing equivalent in the market (backed by market research and
competitive
analysis).
- Industry & Media Recognition
- Strong competitive advantage that prevents imitation, such as Intellectual
Property (IP) rights or high entry barriers.
2.4 Intellectual Property (IP)
Registration
5%
LEVEL 0No consideration or action taken regarding intellectual
property protection.
LEVEL 1IP protection is being considered or planned, but no
formal
application has been filed yet, or the specific form of protection (e.g., patent
vs.
trade secret) is still being determined.
LEVEL 2Currently in the formal process of seeking IP protection
(e.g., pending application for Patent, Petty Patent, Copyright, Trademark, or
identified Trade Secret).
LEVEL 3Intellectual property protection has been granted, or
there
is a clearly established IP Portfolio directly related to the project.